Kate sent over this review in NY Magazine of Ultimate Blogs: Masterworks from the Wide Web, a book that sets out to hand pick the best of the best in terms of the odd 80-million of us out there.
Most of Boxer’s [the author’s] selections don’t read like a new species of writing [and are quite overdone in terms of media coverage; Smoking Gun anyone?], but like very close cousins of once-venerable print genres that have been forced out of public discourse by the shrinkage of major American media: passionate arts criticism, critical theory, colorful polemics, and, above all, the personal essay. Sometimes it seems like blogging is just the apotheosis of the personal essay, the logical heir to 500 years of work by proto-bloggers such as Montaigne, Charles Lamb, G.K. Chesterton, Dorothy Parker, and E. B. White. I see no reason for drawing an artificial line between screen and print.
But I have to admit that I love this thought, and it’s one that I’ve been echoing for years in meetings, at seminars, and pretty much where anyone could possibly be listening. Hell, who wouldn’t want to be compared to Dorothy Parker, that’s quite a compliment for the peeps that made it into the book and onto the author’s lists.